According to documents that somehow reference this lovely first Thanksgiving meal, there’s some very specific foods they ate that if we’re being entirely honest don’t quite fit the bill of our standard turkey dishes. First of all: the things we know for sure. The big harvest consisted of freshly killed deer, wildfowl, cod, bass and a native corn called flint. Honestly, I already like this more than turkey.

Then there’s things we can piece together based on some educated guesses. While we know turkey probably wasn’t on the menu on that first Thanksgiving, it’s safe to assume some duck or geese made it to the table. Back then they stuffed them with onions and nuts. Seafood is also a given, since in those days the sea was still plentiful with fish. Think lobster and eel, for example.
