Christian Bale – The Prestige (2006)
Almost a decade too late to the trend, this Nolan masterpiece has one of the best method actors of his generation play identical twins. Naturally, the fact that they’re twins and not just one really good magician is part of the plot twist, so you’ll only start appreciating the subtle differences in Bale’s performance on subsequent views.

Leonardo DiCaprio – The Man In The Iron Mask (1998)
It’s not the best Leo movie – in fact, it might be one of his worst – but he does play twins in this. He plays Louis XIV and his imprisoned brother Philippe in this movie, but we should probably mention that he won a Razzie for Worst Screen Couple after doing this movie. So, yeah.
